“Know how to solve every problem that has been solved.” “What I cannot create, I do not understand.” — Richard Feynman

The Variational Principle by Hand — Helium in one parameter — every integral shown

Exercises

Quantum Chemistry IUnit 2 · The variational gameThe Variational Principle by Handall problems

Worked example Problem 1 of 8

Helium in one parameter — every integral shown

Problem
Put both electrons of helium () into a 1s Slater orbital with a variable exponent . Compute each expectation value from its integral, assemble , then minimize and compare with the exact hartree.

Solution

The trial is a product of two identical 1s orbitals, one per electron. Its energy splits into one-electron pieces (kinetic + nuclear attraction, doubled) plus the two-electron repulsion. Every piece is an average over , so write each as an explicit integral.

Normalization. The factor is fixed by demanding :

The one identity doing all the work below is .

Nuclear attraction, per electron — the operator averaged over :

With and two electrons: .

Kinetic energy. Use the gradient form — there is the absolute value, , not . Since , we get :

Two electrons: .

Electron–electron repulsion — the one genuinely two-electron integral, over . Expanding in Legendre polynomials and integrating gives the standard 1s result:

Assemble the three pieces:

Predict before reading on. You have . Before minimizing: each electron screens the nucleus from the other, so will the optimal exponent come out above or below the bare charge ?

Check. ✓ — above exact, as the variational principle demands. And : each electron sees a screened nucleus, with screening constant — essentially Slater’s empirical .

Result